| Name | Title | Date Appointed |
| David R. Harrison | Postmaster | 05/26/1864 |
| David R. Harrison | Postmaster | 05/08/1896 |
| William A. Stotlar | Postmaster | 03/15/1898 |
| Americus Gasaway | Postmaster | 05/16/1905 |
| William A. Perrine | Postmaster | 02/09/1909 |
| Alonzo Boren | Postmaster | 06/26/1913 |
| Paul A. Dawson | Acting Postmaster | 04/07/1918 |
| John D. Perrine | Postmaster | 08/29/1919 |
| Americus Gasaway | Postmaster | 01/03/1925 |
| Joel E. Grizzell | Acting Postmaster | 07/16/1928 |
| Joel E. Grizzell | Postmaster | 01/29/1929 |
| Orville W. Lyerla | Acting Postmaster | 09/13/1933 |
| Orville W. Lyerla | Postmaster | 05/03/1934 |
| Esco Niblo Bowen | Acting Postmaster | 08/17/1943 |
| Lee L. Herrin | Acting Postmaster | 06/16/1944 |
| Lee L. Herrin | Postmaster | 04/06/1946 |
| Paul T. Popham | Officer-In-Charge | 12/30/1965 |
| Thomas E. Childers | Acting Postmaster | 03/04/1966 |
| Paul T. Popham | Officer-In-Charge | 08/28/1968 |
| Fred E. Schoonover | Postmaster | 10/04/1968 |
| Richard F. Stalcup | Officer-In-Charge | 12/29/1981 |
| Gordon L. Headley | Postmaster | 05/15/1982 |
| Jimmie L. Bonner | Officer-In-Charge | 07/01/1991 |
| James L. Bushong | Postmaster | 08/10/1991 |
| Robert D. Maurizio | Officer-In-Charge | 03/20/1999 |
| Gordon R. Walker | Postmaster | 06/05/1999 |
| Barry M. White | Officer-In-Charge | 03/14/2002 |
| Barry M. White | Postmaster | 11/16/2002 |
Originally established as HERRIN'S PRAIRIE; name changed to HERRIN on May 8, 1896